Share
A New York federal judge has postponed a decision on Aave’s request to release $71 million in frozen Ethereum tied to the Kelp DAO exploit, ordering both sides to submit additional legal arguments before a June hearing.
According to filings submitted Wednesday in the Southern District of New York, Judge Margaret M. Garnett said Aave LLC had not sufficiently explained how “compounding losses” to users would occur if the restraining notice on the funds remained active. The judge scheduled another hearing for June 5 and directed both parties to file supplemental briefs by May 22.
At the center of the dispute is 30,765 ETH that Arbitrum’s Security Council froze on April 21 after tracing the assets to the April 18 Kelp DAO exploit.
The attack targeted Kelp’s LayerZero-powered bridge and allowed hackers to mint unbacked rsETH, which was later used as collateral on Aave v3 to borrow an estimated $230 million in wrapped ETH. Earlier reports tied the exploit to roughly $190 million in bad debt across DeFi lending markets.
Earlier this month, Gerstein Harrow LLP secured court approval to serve a restraining notice on Arbitrum DAO. The law firm represents families holding about $877 million in unpaid terrorism judgments against North Korea and argued the frozen ETH should be treated as DPRK-linked property because blockchain analytics firms associated the exploit with the Lazarus Group. No court has formally determined that North Korea or Lazarus carried out the attack.
Aave pushed back against that argument in an emergency filing on May 4. Its lawyers argued that stolen crypto does not become the legal property of a thief simply because it passed through attacker-controlled wallets. The company also warned that extended restrictions on the ETH could hurt affected users and interfere with recovery efforts tied to rsETH.
In her latest order, Judge Garnett acknowledged the risks facing Aave users but said the legal questions raised by the dispute require deeper examination. The court asked both sides to address six specific issues, including whether New York’s shelter principle applies to the hacking transactions, how theft differs from fraud under the relevant law, and whether the hackers ever gained a recognizable ownership interest in the stolen assets.
Additional questions focused on creditor priority rights over the frozen ETH and whether a constructive trust could be used to return funds proportionally to affected users. Judge Garnett also asked whether Aave or Arbitrum can identify individual victims well enough to support a pro rata distribution plan.
Days before the latest order, Judge Garnett modified an earlier freeze to allow an Arbitrum governance proposal tied to the recovery effort to continue moving through on-chain voting. The proposal, introduced on May 12, would transfer the 30,765 ETH from Arbitrum’s Security Council wallet to an address controlled by Aave LLC.
While the judge permitted governance participants to proceed without personal liability under the restraining notice, the court preserved the plaintiffs’ legal claim over the ETH. Aave, therefore, cannot freely use the assets until the dispute is resolved.
Elsewhere in the recovery effort, Aave and Kelp DAO said Tuesday they had taken steps to restore rsETH backing. The attacker’s rsETH on Arbitrum has already been burned, while nearly $278 million worth of replacement assets is expected to be restored over the next two weeks through funds managed by the Aave Recovery Guardian multisignature wallet.
Read more about
Best crypto platforms
May 2026
Deep Dives
CZ says he prefers AI “shovels” over AI itself as infrastructure race intensifies
Tokenization aided by MiCA, insights with Wojciech Kaszycki
Crypto’s X feed turns into a live tape for policy, halving and AI fear
Crypto conference season looked loud in 2025 but it barely made a dent in crypto media traffic
The Block’s new CEO bet: Azuki’s Steve Chung and a $10M institutional push
In conversation with Vasily Shilov, CBDO at SwapSpace: Privacy, DEXs, and what the conference season actually revealed
CLARITY Act deadline turns into Congress’s last real shot at crypto rules
The latest trends & technologies in crypto crime | Opinion
CZ’s prison‑born ‘Freedom of Money’ lights up crypto’s fault lines
Inside SCRYPT’s bid to be the OS for institutional crypto
Related News
Aave vote targets $71M Kelp exploit funds
Aave completes liquidation of Kelp DAO attacker’s final rsETH positions
Uphold rejects NYAG claims after $5M CredEarn settlement
Get crypto market analysis and curated news delivered right to your inbox every week.
You have successfully joined our subscriber list.
